IB English Paper 2 Sample Response: A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale - Complete Notes

Introduction

The IB English Paper 2 exam requires students to write a comparative essay on at least two of the literary works studied in Part 3 of the course. This guide will focus on Henrik Ibsen's A Doll's House and Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale, providing comprehensive notes and analysis to help you craft a strong, insightful response. This comprehensive guide will explore the intricacies of these two works, comparing and contrasting their themes, characters, literary devices, and narrative techniques. Through this analysis, you will gain a deeper understanding of how these texts critique societal norms and highlight the struggle for identity and freedom.

Understanding the Texts

A Doll's House by Henrik Ibsen

Henrik Ibsen's A Doll's House is a three-act play that delves into the constraints of societal norms and gender roles in the late 19th century. The plot follows the protagonist, Nora Helmer, as she grapples with the limitations imposed on her by her husband, Torvald, and society at large. The play traces Nora’s journey of self-discovery, culminating in her decision to leave her husband and children to find her own identity. This radical move underscores the play’s critique of the traditional roles of men and women within marriage.

The central themes of A Doll's House include gender roles and marriage, individual versus society, and deception and self-deception. The play critiques the traditional roles of men and women within marriage, illustrating how these roles confine and suppress individual desires. Nora initially conforms to the role of the dutiful wife but ultimately rejects it to seek her own identity. Torvald’s patronizing attitude reflects the societal norms that restrict women's independence.

The theme of individual versus society is evident in Nora’s journey, representing the conflict between personal desires and societal expectations. Her final decision to leave is an assertion of individual freedom against societal norms. Deception plays a crucial role in the Helmers’ marriage, with Nora hiding her financial dealings and Torvald presenting a façade of moral superiority. The unraveling of these deceptions leads to Nora’s awakening and Torvald’s realization of his superficial values.

The characters in A Doll's House are complex and multi-dimensional. Nora Helmer is the protagonist who evolves from a submissive wife to an independent woman. Torvald Helmer, Nora's controlling and patronizing husband, embodies the patriarchal society that confines Nora. Krogstad, a lawyer who blackmails Nora, reveals his own vulnerabilities, adding depth to his character. Mrs. Linde, Nora’s old friend, provides a contrast to Nora’s character and experiences, highlighting the different ways women navigate societal constraints.

The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood

Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale is a dystopian novel set in the Republic of Gilead, a theocratic society where women are subjugated. The protagonist, Offred, is a Handmaid whose sole purpose is to bear children for the ruling class. The novel follows Offred’s struggle for identity and resistance against the oppressive regime. Atwood’s portrayal of Gilead serves as a stark warning about the dangers of totalitarianism and the extreme subjugation of women.

The themes of The Handmaid's Tale include power and control, gender and patriarchy, and identity and resistance. The novel explores the mechanisms of control used by totalitarian regimes, highlighting how power is wielded to subjugate women. Offred’s role as a Handmaid strips her of her individuality and reduces her to a reproductive vessel. The regime’s strict control over women’s bodies and identities underscores the dangers of patriarchal dominance.

Offred’s struggle for identity and resistance is a central theme in the novel. Despite the oppressive environment, Offred maintains her sense of self through memories of the past and small acts of defiance. Her internal struggle and resistance against the regime highlight the human spirit's resilience in the face of extreme oppression.

The characters in The Handmaid's Tale are richly drawn, each representing different facets of the dystopian society. Offred, the protagonist, narrates her life under the Gileadean regime, providing a personal and intimate perspective on the oppression she faces. Serena Joy, the Wife of Offred’s Commander, is also trapped in the patriarchal system, despite her higher status. The Commander, a high-ranking official in Gilead, engages in illicit activities, revealing the hypocrisy of the regime. Moira, Offred’s friend, embodies resistance against the regime, serving as a symbol of defiance and hope.

Comparative Analysis

Themes

.

Offred's Transformative Journey in "The Handmaid's Tale"

Offred's transformation unfolds within the oppressive regime of Gilead, where she initially resigns herself to her fate as a "handmaid." As the novel progresses, her defiance becomes more pronounced and bold:

• Offred often indulges in "illegal thoughts" and engages in small acts of rebellion, such as sneaking butter for use as lotion.

• She forms alliances with other handmaids, mainly Ofglen, and participates in underground activities of the resistance group Mayday.

• In the final moments of the novel, Offred says, "And so I step up, into the darkness within; or else the light," symbolizing her willingness to take a leap of faith and assert her agency, even in the face of danger.

Offred's journey of personal liberation within the patriarchal society of Gilead showcases the transformative power of individual agency in the face of oppression.

Nora Helmer's Journey to Self-Realization in "A Doll's House"

Similarly, in "A Doll's House," Nora Helmer undergoes a profound transformation from a seemingly frivolous and subservient wife to a woman determined to forge her own identity and live by her own values:

• Initially, Nora is depicted as a conventional image of the devoted wife, as illustrated when she tells Torvald, "I would never dream of doing anything you didn't want me to."

• However, Nora's major transgression of borrowing money earlier in their marriage, without Torvald's knowledge, highlights her deceitful demeanor and hints at the dysfunction within their patriarchal society and household.

• As the play progresses, Nora's disillusionment with societal expectations becomes increasingly evident, culminating in her realization that she must assert her independence to live authentically.

• Nora's decision to escape from confinement symbolizes her rejection of societal norms and her journey towards self-dependence and personal empowerment.

Ibsen's play is a critical examination of 19th-century marriage norms and gender roles, with Nora's journey being symbolic of the broader struggle for women's rights and autonomy in a male-dominated society.

Contrasting Outcomes of the Transformative Journeys

While both Offred and Nora navigate challenges and confront societal norms, their journeys culminate in different outcomes:

• Offred's journey in "The Handmaid's Tale" ends with her surrendering herself to the unknown, leaving her ultimate fate ambiguous. Atwood employs ambiguity throughout the novel, leaving readers uncertain of Offred's fate.

• In contrast, Nora's decisive action in "A Doll's House" marks a definitive break from societal constraints, symbolizing her empowerment and self-realization. Her confrontation with Torvald showcases her determination in pursuing personal freedom and utility after her disillusionment with the image of her marriage and societal gender roles.

Conclusion

Through their narratives, Atwood and Ibsen offer insights into the complexities of individual agency within oppressive societies, highlighting the different outcomes of transformative journeys of personal liberation. While Offred's fate remains uncertain, Nora's decisive actions lead to a definitive resolution, empowering readers who are facing various forms of restrictions to advocate for themselves boldly

The Theme of Power in "The Handmaid's Tale" and "A Doll's House"

Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale" and Henrik Ibsen's "A Doll's House" both explore the theme of power and its impact on the protagonists, Offred and Nora Helmer, respectively. Through their narratives, the authors delve into the complexities of power dynamics within oppressive societal contexts.

Power Dynamics in "The Handmaid's Tale"

In "The Handmaid's Tale," Atwood portrays a dystopian society where power is concentrated in the hands of a few, leading to the subjugation of women. The setting of Gilead, with its strict hierarchical structure, reflects the oppressive power dynamics at play:

• The Republic of Gilead is a theocratic state that has overthrown the United States government, centralizing power in the hands of a patriarchal regime.

• Women's roles are rigidly defined, with Handmaids serving as a means of reproduction for the elite.

• The Commander's house, where much of the novel takes place, symbolizes the power dynamics and control exerted over individuals, especially women, in private spaces.

Atwood's portrayal of authoritative figures, such as the Commander and Serena Joy, reveals the hypocrisy and contradictions inherent in the system. Despite their positions of power, they are unable to adhere to the very structures they have put in place, exposing the flaws within the patriarchal society.

Nora's Struggle for Power in "A Doll's House"

In "A Doll's House," Ibsen presents a different perspective on power, focusing on Nora's journey towards self-realization and empowerment within a male-dominated society. The setting of the Helmers' home, which serves as both a domestic space and a symbolic representation of societal norms, highlights the constraints imposed on Nora by society and her own expectations.

• The living room, where much of the play's action takes place, symbolizes the societal stage upon which Nora performs her assigned role as a dutiful wife and mother.

• Nora's decision to leave through the door at the end of the play is profoundly significant, as it symbolizes her exit from the constraints of her marriage and societal expectations.

Ibsen's use of setting, such as the Tarantella dance and the Christmas tree, further emphasizes Nora's internal struggle and the facade of her perfect life falling apart. Through Nora's transformative journey, Ibsen offers a glimmer of hope and empowerment, suggesting that even the most powerless individuals can break free from societal constraints.

Contrasting Outcomes and Emotional Responses

While both Atwood and Ibsen explore the theme of power, their narratives evoke different emotional responses in the reader:

• Atwood's portrayal of the authoritative figures in "The Handmaid's Tale" elicits a sense of resentment and animosity towards the injustices committed by those in power.

• Ibsen's depiction of Nora's transformative journey in "A Doll's House" evokes a sense of empowerment and hope, as readers witness her break free from societal constraints and pursue her own identity.

The contrasting outcomes of Offred's and Nora's journeys further highlight the complexities of power and its impact on individuals. While Offred's fate remains ambiguous, leaving readers pondering the outcomes of her rebellion, Nora's decisive actions lead to a definitive resolution, empowering readers to advocate for themselves boldly in the face of oppression.

The Theme of Conflict in "The Handmaid's Tale" and "A Doll's House"

Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale" and Henrik Ibsen's "A Doll's House" explore the theme of conflict on multiple levels, from the societal to the personal. Both authors delve into the struggles of their protagonists as they navigate oppressive environments and confront the expectations imposed upon them by society.

Societal Conflict in "The Handmaid's Tale"

In "The Handmaid's Tale," Atwood portrays a dystopian society where women are subjected to rigid roles and strict control by the patriarchal regime of Gilead. The conflict arises from the clash between the state's totalitarian control and the individual's desire for freedom and autonomy:

• The Republic of Gilead is a theocratic state that has overthrown the United States government, centralizing power in the hands of a patriarchal regime.

• Women's roles are rigidly defined, with Handmaids serving as a means of reproduction for the elite.

• The conflict is evident in the oppressive rules and rituals imposed on women, such as the Ceremony, where Handmaids are forced to engage in ritualized sex with their Commanders in an attempt to conceive children.

Atwood's portrayal of the conflict between the individual and the state highlights the consequences of totalitarian control and the resilience of the human spirit in the face of adversity.

Personal Conflict in "A Doll's House"

In "A Doll's House," Ibsen focuses on the personal conflict within Nora Helmer as she navigates the expectations of her husband, Torvald, and the constraints of 19th-century Norwegian society. The conflict arises from Nora's growing awareness of her own identity and the realization that her marriage is built on a foundation of lies and oppression:

• Nora's decision to borrow money without Torvald's knowledge to save his life leads to a conflict between her desire to help him and the societal norms that prohibit women from engaging in financial transactions.

• The conflict intensifies as Nora's disillusionment with her marriage and Torvald's true character becomes evident.

• The climax of the play occurs when Nora confronts Torvald and decides to leave her family in pursuit of personal freedom and self-discovery.

Ibsen's portrayal of the conflict within Nora's marriage and her struggle for independence reflects the broader societal conflict between traditional gender roles and the emerging feminist movement of the time.

Contrasting Outcomes and Emotional Responses

While both Atwood and Ibsen explore the theme of conflict, their narratives evoke different emotional responses in the reader:

• Atwood's portrayal of the conflict between the individual and the state in "The Handmaid's Tale" elicits a sense of outrage and a desire for resistance against oppressive systems.

• Ibsen's depiction of Nora's personal conflict in "A Doll's House" evokes a sense of empowerment and hope, as readers witness her break free from societal constraints and pursue her own identity.

The contrasting outcomes of Offred's and Nora's journeys further highlight the complexities of conflict and its impact on individuals. While Offred's fate remains ambiguous, leaving readers pondering the outcomes of her rebellion, Nora's decisive actions lead to a definitive resolution, empowering readers to advocate for themselves boldly in the face of oppression.

The Significance of "Home" in "The Handmaid's Tale" and "A Doll's House"

The concept of "home" plays a crucial role in both Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale" and Henrik Ibsen's "A Doll's House." In these works, the authors use the setting of the home to explore themes of power, oppression, and the struggle for personal autonomy.

The Commander's House in "The Handmaid's Tale"

In "The Handmaid's Tale," the setting of the Commander's house serves as a microcosm of the oppressive society of Gilead. This domestic space, where much of the novel's action takes place, symbolizes the control and surveillance exerted over individuals, especially women, in their private lives.

• Offred's room, described as sparse and surveilled, reflects her lack of freedom and individuality within the confines of the Commander's household.

• The household represents the power dynamics and the personal-public dichotomy present in Gilead, where even the most intimate spaces are subject to the regime's scrutiny and regulation.

• The Commander's house, as a symbol of the patriarchal authority, highlights the ways in which the oppressive societal structures of Gilead permeate into the private sphere, leaving no space for the individual to truly be free.

The Helmers' Home in "A Doll's House"

In "A Doll's House," the setting of the Helmers' home is both a typical domestic space and a symbolic representation of the societal norms and expectations of 19th-century Norwegian society.

• The Helmers' home, which should be a place of safety and comfort, is instead a "doll's house," where Nora is expected to play the role of the dutiful wife and mother.

• The living room, where much of the play's action takes place, symbolizes the societal stage upon which Nora and Torvald perform their assigned roles, with Nora playing the part of the subservient wife and Torvald that of the authoritative husband.

• The door to the Helmers' home represents the boundary between the private world of the family and the public eye, as well as the barrier that Nora must cross to achieve her independence.

The Significance of "Home" in Both Works

In both "The Handmaid's Tale" and "A Doll's House," the authors use the setting of the home to highlight the oppressive nature of the societal structures that their protagonists must navigate.

• The home, which is traditionally seen as a place of refuge and safety, becomes a site of confinement and control, reflecting the broader societal constraints imposed on the characters.

• The domestic spaces in these works serve as microcosms of the larger power dynamics and gender-based oppression present in the societies depicted.

• By subverting the traditional notion of the home, Atwood and Ibsen challenge the readers to question the societal norms and expectations that dictate the lives of their protagonists.

Through their use of the home as a setting, both Atwood and Ibsen invite the reader to reflect on the complex relationship between the individual and the societal structures that seek to define and confine them. The home, as a symbol of both comfort and constraint, becomes a powerful tool in the authors' exploration of themes of power, resistance, and the pursuit of personal autonomy.

Gender Roles and Marriage

The theme of gender roles and marriage is central to both A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale, albeit explored in different contexts. A Doll's House examines traditional gender roles within the confines of marriage. Nora initially conforms to the role of the dutiful wife but ultimately rejects it to seek her own identity. Torvald’s patronizing attitude reflects the societal norms that restrict women's independence. The play critiques these traditional roles, illustrating how they confine and suppress individual desires.

In contrast, The Handmaid's Tale presents an extreme form of gender roles where women are categorized into rigid roles such as Wives, Handmaids, and Marthas. Offred’s role as a Handmaid strips her of her individuality and reduces her to a reproductive vessel. The regime’s strict control over women’s bodies and identities highlights the dangers of patriarchal dominance. Offred’s struggle for identity and resistance against the regime underscores the novel’s critique of gender roles and patriarchy.

Despite the differences in context, both texts critique the restrictive nature of gender roles and the impact on individual identity. While Ibsen portrays a more personal and domestic struggle, Atwood’s depiction is broader, encompassing societal and systemic oppression. Both protagonists, Nora and Offred, seek to reclaim their identities in different ways: Nora through leaving her family, and Offred through small acts of rebellion and eventual escape.

Individual vs. Society

The theme of individual versus society is prominent in both A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale. In A Doll's House, Nora’s journey represents the conflict between personal desires and societal expectations. Her final decision to leave is an assertion of individual freedom against societal norms. The play illustrates how societal constraints can stifle individual aspirations and the importance of personal freedom.

In The Handmaid's Tale, Offred’s struggle against the totalitarian regime represents a broader conflict between individual freedom and societal control. The rigid structures of Gilead suppress personal identity and enforce conformity. Offred’s internal resistance and small acts of defiance highlight the importance of maintaining one's sense of self in the face of overwhelming oppression.

Both works depict the tension between individual aspirations and societal constraints. Nora’s rebellion is more personal and intimate, while Offred’s resistance is against an entire system. The outcomes also differ: Nora’s departure is a definitive act of liberation, while Offred’s fate remains uncertain, reflecting the ongoing struggle for autonomy.

Deception and Self-Deception

Deception and self-deception are key themes in both A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale. In A Doll's House, deception plays a crucial role in the Helmers’ marriage. Nora hides her financial dealings from Torvald, while Torvald presents a façade of moral superiority. The unraveling of these deceptions leads to Nora’s awakening and Torvald’s realization of his superficial values.

In The Handmaid's Tale, deception is a survival mechanism for characters in Gilead. Offred must constantly navigate between obedience and resistance, using deception to survive. The regime itself is built on deception, presenting a façade of religious righteousness while engaging in corruption and exploitation.

Deception in both texts serves as a means of survival and control. While Nora’s deceptions are personal and lead to self-discovery, Offred’s are imposed by the regime and serve as acts of resistance. Both narratives reveal the destructive nature of deceit on personal and societal levels.

Characters

Protagonists

The protagonists of A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale are central to the exploration of the themes and the critique of societal norms.

Nora Helmer in A Doll's House begins as a seemingly naive and submissive wife but evolves into a self-aware and assertive individual. Her transformation challenges the traditional roles assigned to women and underscores the importance of personal freedom. Nora’s journey is marked by her realization of the limitations imposed on her by society and her decision to break free from these constraints.

Offred in The Handmaid's Tale is marked by her inner strength and resilience. She navigates a hostile environment, using her intellect and memories of the past to maintain her sense of self. Despite the oppressive regime, Offred’s internal resistance and small acts of defiance highlight her struggle for identity and autonomy. Her narrative is marked by a constant tension between survival and resistance.

Both protagonists undergo significant transformations, driven by their desire for freedom and self-identity. Nora’s journey is more overt and decisive, culminating in her departure, whereas Offred’s is subtler, marked by inner resistance and hope for a future escape. Both characters symbolize the struggle against oppressive systems, whether societal or political.

Antagonists

The antagonists in A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale play crucial roles in enforcing and perpetuating the systems of control that the protagonists struggle against.

In A Doll's House, Torvald Helmer represents the patriarchal society that confines Nora. His inability to see beyond societal norms makes him an antagonist to Nora’s liberation. Torvald’s character embodies the traditional roles and values that restrict women’s independence and self-identity.

In The Handmaid's Tale, the Commander and Serena Joy embody the oppressive regime of Gilead. The Commander’s hypocrisy and Serena Joy’s complicity highlight different facets of the regime’s control over women. Despite their higher status, both characters are also trapped within the patriarchal system, reflecting the pervasive nature of the regime’s control.

Both sets of antagonists enforce and perpetuate the systems of control that the protagonists struggle against. Torvald’s character is more personal and intimate, reflecting societal norms, while the Commander and Serena Joy represent broader institutionalized oppression. The antagonists’ actions are crucial in highlighting the protagonists’ resistance and growth.

Literary Devices

Symbolism

Symbolism is a key literary device used in both A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale to enhance the themes and deepen the reader’s understanding of the characters’ struggles.

In A Doll's House, the title itself symbolizes the confined and controlled life of Nora. The Christmas tree represents Nora’s position in the household, initially vibrant and decorated, but later stripped and neglected. These symbols underscore the play’s critique of societal norms and the limitations imposed on women.

In The Handmaid's Tale, the color red symbolizes fertility and control, as seen in the Handmaids’ uniforms. The Wall represents the regime’s brutal enforcement of rules and the constant presence of death. These symbols highlight the extreme subjugation of women and the oppressive nature of the regime.

Symbolism in both texts enhances the themes of control and resistance. Ibsen uses domestic symbols to critique societal norms, while Atwood employs more stark and oppressive imagery to reflect the dystopian setting. Both authors use symbolism to deepen the reader’s understanding of the characters’ struggles.

Imagery

Imagery is another important literary device used in both A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale to create a vivid sense of the protagonists’ environments.

In A Doll's House, Ibsen uses domestic imagery to depict the Helmer household as a ‘doll’s house,’ emphasizing the artificial and controlled environment. The imagery highlights the confined and superficial nature of Nora’s life and her desire for freedom.

In The Handmaid's Tale, Atwood uses vivid and often brutal imagery to highlight the stark reality of life in Gilead. Offred’s memories of the past provide contrasting images of freedom and normalcy. The imagery underscores the oppressive nature of the regime and Offred’s struggle for identity.

Both texts use imagery to create a vivid sense of the protagonists’ environments. Ibsen’s domestic imagery contrasts with Atwood’s dystopian visuals, yet both serve to underscore the central themes of control and resistance. The imagery in both works enriches the narrative and provides deeper insight into the characters’ experiences.

Narrative Techniques

The narrative techniques used in A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale effectively convey the protagonists’ inner conflicts and societal critiques.

In A Doll's House, the play’s structure follows a linear progression, leading to a climax where Nora confronts her reality and decides to leave. The dialogue-driven narrative reveals character dynamics and societal critiques. The linear structure builds towards a clear resolution, highlighting Nora’s transformation and the play’s critique of societal norms.

In The Handmaid's Tale, Atwood uses a non-linear narrative, with Offred’s present interwoven with memories and flashbacks. The first-person perspective provides an intimate view of Offred’s thoughts and experiences. The fragmented narrative reflects the uncertainty and complexity of Offred’s situation, enhancing the reader’s engagement with her story.

Both narrative techniques effectively convey the protagonists’ inner conflicts and societal critiques. Ibsen’s linear structure builds towards a clear resolution, while Atwood’s fragmented narrative reflects the uncertainty and complexity of Offred’s situation. The different techniques highlight the unique challenges faced by Nora and Offred, enhancing the reader’s engagement with their stories.

Conclusion

Both A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale offer rich texts for comparative analysis, exploring themes of gender roles, individual versus society, and deception. Through their protagonists, literary devices, and narrative techniques, Ibsen and Atwood critique societal norms and highlight the enduring struggle for identity and freedom. Understanding these elements will enable you to craft a comprehensive and insightful comparative essay for your IB English Paper 2 exam.

Tips for Writing Your Essay

To craft a strong comparative essay on A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale, it is important to structure your essay clearly, using a comparative structure that allows you to discuss each text in relation to the other. Use evidence effectively, supporting your points with specific examples and quotations from the texts. Focus on analysis and interpretation rather than simply summarizing the plots, and engage critically with the authors’ techniques and messages. Plan your time effectively, allocating time for planning, writing, and reviewing your essay to ensure clarity and coherence. By following these guidelines and utilizing the insights provided in this guide, you will be well-equipped to write a strong comparative essay on A Doll's House and The Handmaid's Tale for your IB English Paper 2 exam.